Why should you do the Butterbeer Experience?
If you love the idea of wandering into a slice of Wizarding World while in New York – complete with Butterbeer, wands, magical creatures and all the cozy chaos of a fantastical marketplace – this place is a gem. The store doesn’t feel like your usual retail stop; it feels like a mini-experience tucked into the Flatiron district, perfect for a fun break from sightseeing or a rainy-day rescue.
Whether you’re a die-hard fan of Harry Potter or Fantastic Beasts, or just curious about the hype, the combination of immersive theming, exclusive merchandise and that famous frothy Butterbeer makes this more than just a shop. It’s a quick, magical detour that delivers the feels without needing a full-day commitment.
How to find the Harry Potter Store Butterbeer Experience?
You’ll find the store at 935 Broadway, New York, NY 10010, in the Flatiron/NoMad area. It’s on the street running along the ‘back’ edge of the Flatiron Building.
It basically runs along the whole street, so you can enter at either end – handy!
What do I get with a New York Pass?
Entry to the store itself is free, but with your pass, a classic Butterbeer in the café is on us!
Show your pass at the bar to claim one classic Butterbeer, served in a souvenir cup. They even have a little washing station, so don’t worry, you don’t need to put a sticky tankard in your bag.
Cheers!
What is there to do/see?
Walking in, you realize this isn’t just floor-to-ceiling merchandise: the store is carved into themed zones that feel like you’re stepping straight into the Wizarding World.
Honeydukes Sweet Shop
In the section modeled after the colorful Hogsmeade sweet shop, you’ll find classic magical indulgences: chocolate frogs, Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans, and more. Perfect if your inner kid, or your sweet tooth, insists on a souvenir.
Olivanders
This area is styled like the classic Diagon Alley wand shop, from the books/films. It features walls of ‘dusty’ wand boxes and even an interactive display so you can see which wand belongs to which wizard. Ready to find out which wand is choosing you?
Sighs in sugary contentment
Fantastic Beasts
Creatures from the wizarding world, of course, make an appearance: think owls, nifflers, and other lovable (or sometimes scary) companions, plush toys, figurines and fun décor. Make sure you check out the exclusive NYC items that you can’t get anywhere else!
Downstairs treasure trove
If you head downstairs (yes, via a giant phoenix staircase like the one into Dumbledore’s office), even more magic awaits. A stationery store (I may have squealed), a bookshop (including special/collector editions of the novels), Hogwarts house-themed apparel (scarves, ties, jumpers), themed jewellery, keepsakes, and more.
A book-lovers paradise
The Butterbeer Bar (aka the main event)
At one end of the store lies the atmospheric Butterbeer Bar – imagine barrels, soft glowing lights, copper-piped ceilings and a cascade of hundreds (almost 1,000!) “floating” Butterbeer bottles tumbling above you. It really sets the mood – you’ve stepped straight into a cosy café in Hogsmeade.
What you’ll find:
-
Classic draft Butterbeer – the one included with the New York Pass. Frothy, sweet, it kind of tastes like a fizzy butterscotch, or vanilla-cream soda vibe.
-
Other treats (pay-as-you-go):
-
Frozen Butterbeer (slushie-style).
-
Butterbeer ice-cream – yes, really. Cold and creamy, perfect for a warmer day!
-
Regular snacks and themed desserts – cookies, cupcakes shaped like owls or wands, other wizarding-world-style goodies.
Depending on when you visit, I recommend checking the line sporadically during your time in the shop. When I first arrived it was quite long, but when I checked again later there was no line at all!
The sugar hit is coming when you see this...
Optional extras (at additional cost)
Green-screen “Broomstick” Video/Photo Experience – downstairs, you can pay to “ride a broomstick” over New York (or somewhere suitably magical) and get a keepsake video or photo. It’s not included with the pass, but it’s a fun extra for fans wanting something more interactive and memorable.
Exclusive New York / MACUSA-label merch – the store is known for items you won’t easily find elsewhere, like exclusive labels on bottled Butterbeer, and other items tied to the US-based magical world (hello, MACUSA).
Best photo spots
Because I’m a committed researcher (okay fine, a big HP nerd) – I scoped out some of the most Instagram-worthy corners:
-
Under the cascade of glowing Butterbeer bottles at the bar: perfect to capture that ‘floating’ bottle magic vibe.
-
The wand-shop display: wand in hand, dramatic lighting, vintage-style shelving: very Ollivanders-esque.
-
The Hagrid-height wall: great for sheer silliness, test how tall you are compared to a giant… not very it turns out.
-
Honeydukes: if you’re a sucker for cute bright colors and a sweet treat, then this is the spot for you.
To be completely transparent, the boots add on an extra inch or two...
Facilities & practicalities
-
There’s no time limit once you’re inside – so you can browse, sip, shop and explore at your own pace. (I lazed around with my Butterbeer, browsing the magical perfection!)
-
It’s nice and roomy (for NYC!) and air-conditioned – a lovely little escape if you’re sightseeing on a hot (or rainy) day.
-
As with all popular NYC spots, it can get busy, especially near the bar or at peak hours. If you care about comfort or good photos, consider visiting earlier or later in the day.
-
There are restrooms available, located downstairs.
Where to go next
-
If you’re already nearby, check out the surrounding Flatiron / NoMad area for lunch or coffee – a good chance to compare the muggle world and the wizarding one.
-
The Flatiron is on the Big Bus route, so it’s a great spot to hop off and back on during your sightseeing.
This magical creature may or may not have come home with me...
Final thoughts
The Harry Potter New York Butterbeer Experience is a little piece of wizarding magic dropped into the middle of Manhattan – and as a fan (or casual tourist) it really delivers. Well worth a visit, you could easily spend an hour or more here soaking up the magic, longer if you’re deciding whether you’d prefer to take home a niffler or a hippogriff... Sadly neither would fit in my suitcase.
So grab your pass, raise your tankard and enjoy a little bit of Hogwarts in busy, magical New York.
Enjoyed this little slice of New York?
Take your trip to the next level with our complete guide to the Museum of Broadway or our complete guide to the Empire State Building, all filled with visitor hacks and money-saving tips.
With The New York Pass®, you can skip the stress and save big on Empire State Building tickets plus dozens of other must-see attractions, all with one easy-to-use pass.
🗽 Don't explore the Big Apple without this
💰 How much can you really save in NYC?
